CIPA Fun

Jeff has kindly sent over Judge Walton’s November 15 CIPA ruling (4MB), which was declassified and released Friday. This is the ruling the one that Fitzgerald is appealing.

Walton lays out his ruling carefully. There are two kinds of information at issue: (a) information supporting Libby’s argument that he is so important that he can’t be expected to remember the details of the covert spy’s lives he has ruined, and (b) information supporting Libby’s argument that he was responding to Wilson’s "findings regarding Iraq’s relationship with Niger" on the merits, and not trying to out a CIA NOC.

Share this entry

Payback's a Bitch

Share this entry

Heading the Sheriff Off at the Pass

Share this entry

I'll Show You Mine If You Show Me Yours

Share this entry

Judge to Libby: No, Jurors Are Not Dumb

Share this entry

Libby's Team Pulls a Fitzgerald

Share this entry

Shredding Dick

Share this entry

Fitzgerald Leaves Them Shaking Their Heads

Share this entry

Woodward's State of Denial and Plame

Share this entry

Libby Case–CIPA Update

Jeff sent me the latest filing from the Plame case, in which Fitz updates Judge Walton about where the discrepancies are wrt classified information. It doesn’t look like any graymail attempt is going to fly–there just don’t seem to be that many outstanding issues (then again, the whole graymail thing might just be an attempt to plant a cause for appeal, so they can keep Scooter out of the clink long enough for Bush to pardon him).

That said, there are ongoing disagreements about the material relating to Wilson and his trip to Niger. Fitzgerald addresses 17 documents relating to "Wilson/Niger." Five of them are unclassified, so Libby will of course be able to use those (I wonder whether this is material that showed up in the SSCI report?) One involves handwritten notes. And Exhibit 71, I’m guessing, is the INR memo (Libby’s team will get "Attachment 1" but no other attachments, which in the case of the INR memo would be Rohn’s notes). But there are five exhibits for which Libby’s team has not yet accepted the government’s redactions.

Oh to be a fly in the next CIPA hearing, assuming these don’t get worked out. Walton, of course, is Read more

Share this entry